Allegations of Research Misconduct Policy
The Paraskevi Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies (PJIDS), published by Paraskevi Academic Dimosiefsi Ltd., is committed to upholding the highest standards of academic integrity, research transparency and responsible scholarly publishing. The journal considers research misconduct a serious violation of scholarly and professional responsibilities and does not tolerate practices that compromise the credibility, originality or reliability of academic research.
This policy establishes the procedures for identifying, reporting, assessing and investigating allegations of research misconduct involving submitted manuscripts, accepted articles and published scholarly works.
1. Definition of Research Misconduct
Research misconduct refers to deliberate, reckless or otherwise serious violations of accepted standards of research integrity and scholarly publishing. It includes practices that undermine the authenticity, reliability, originality or ethical conduct of research.
Research misconduct may occur during research design, data collection, analysis, manuscript preparation, peer review or publication.
2. Forms of Research Misconduct
PJIDS recognises the following, among other practices, as potential forms of research misconduct:
2.1 Plagiarism
Presenting another person's ideas, words, data, findings, figures or other intellectual contributions as one's own without appropriate acknowledgement or citation.
2.2 Data Fabrication
Inventing research data, observations, experimental results, participant responses or findings that were not actually obtained through the reported research process.
2.3 Data Falsification
Manipulating, altering, omitting or misrepresenting research materials, procedures, data or results in ways that produce misleading scholarly conclusions.
2.4 Duplicate and Redundant Publication
Submitting or publishing substantially identical research in multiple journals or publications without appropriate disclosure, justification or permission.
2.5 Image and Figure Manipulation
Inappropriately altering, fabricating, selectively manipulating or misrepresenting photographs, figures, images, charts or other visual research materials.
2.6 Authorship Misconduct
Including individuals who have not made legitimate scholarly contributions, excluding eligible contributors, manipulating author order or claiming authorship without appropriate responsibility and consent.
2.7 Citation Manipulation
Deliberately manipulating references, citations or citation practices to misrepresent scholarly influence, inflate citation counts or distort the academic record.
2.8 Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest
Failing to disclose financial, personal, professional or institutional relationships that may improperly influence research, manuscript preparation, peer review or editorial decisions.
2.9 Unethical Research Practices
Conducting research involving human participants, animals, personal information or sensitive data without required ethical approval, informed consent or appropriate safeguards.
2.10 Misrepresentation of Research Contributions
Misrepresenting research methods, institutional affiliations, funding sources, qualifications, experimental procedures or scholarly contributions.
3. Reporting Suspected Research Misconduct
Authors, reviewers, editors, readers, researchers and other interested parties may report suspected research misconduct to the editorial office of PJIDS.
Reports should provide sufficient information to allow the journal to assess the allegation. Where available, the report should include:
- The title and publication details of the manuscript or article concerned.
- The names of the authors involved.
- A clear description of the suspected misconduct.
- Relevant evidence, documentation or supporting materials.
- References to affected sections, figures, tables or datasets.
- Any additional information that may assist the investigation.
Allegations may be submitted confidentially. Anonymous reports may also be considered where credible and verifiable supporting information is provided.
4. Initial Assessment of Allegations
Upon receiving an allegation, the editorial office will conduct an initial assessment to determine whether the reported concern falls within the journal's research integrity and publication ethics responsibilities.
The initial assessment may consider:
- The seriousness and nature of the allegation.
- The credibility and relevance of the available evidence.
- Whether the alleged conduct constitutes a potential breach of research integrity.
- Whether additional information or independent expertise is required.
Allegations that are clearly unsupported or outside the journal's remit may be closed after appropriate consideration.
5. Investigation Procedures
Where an allegation warrants further examination, PJIDS may initiate an investigation led by the Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately designated independent editorial representative.
The investigation may involve:
- Examining the submitted manuscript or published article.
- Reviewing original research data, laboratory records or supporting materials.
- Examining similarity reports and relevant source documents.
- Assessing figures, images, tables and statistical results.
- Requesting explanations and supporting evidence from the authors.
- Consulting independent subject experts or editorial board members.
- Contacting the relevant author's institution or research organisation where appropriate.
Individuals directly implicated in an allegation must not participate in determining its outcome.
6. Communication with Authors
Where appropriate, the corresponding author and other relevant authors will be informed of the allegation and given an opportunity to respond.
Authors may be requested to provide original datasets, research documentation, ethical approval records, consent information or other evidence relevant to the investigation.
Failure to respond or provide reasonably requested supporting information may be considered when determining the appropriate editorial action. However, failure to respond alone does not automatically establish misconduct.
7. Institutional Involvement
Where an allegation involves serious research misconduct, PJIDS may refer the matter to the relevant author's institution, research organisation, funding body or other appropriate authority for independent investigation.
The journal recognises that institutions may have access to original research records and investigative procedures that are beyond the journal's direct authority.
Institutional findings may be considered when determining appropriate editorial action.
8. Possible Outcomes of an Investigation
Following an assessment or investigation, the journal may take one or more of the following actions, depending on the nature and seriousness of the findings:
- Close the allegation where insufficient evidence of misconduct is established.
- Request clarification or additional documentation from the authors.
- Require corrections to the manuscript or published article.
- Reject a manuscript under consideration.
- Issue an expression of concern regarding a published article.
- Publish an erratum or corrigendum where appropriate.
- Retract a published article where justified.
- Notify the relevant institution or research organisation.
- Restrict or decline future submissions where serious or repeated misconduct is established and such action is justified.
9. Actions Before Publication
Where suspected misconduct is identified during manuscript evaluation, the journal may suspend the editorial process while the matter is assessed.
Depending on the findings, the manuscript may be returned for clarification, rejected or referred to an appropriate institution or authority.
10. Actions After Publication
Where research misconduct is identified after publication, PJIDS will take appropriate steps to protect the integrity of the scholarly record.
Possible actions include:
- Publishing a correction notice.
- Issuing an expression of concern.
- Retracting the affected article.
- Adding appropriate notices and links to the article record.
- Communicating relevant findings to appropriate institutions or authorities.
Post-publication actions will be documented transparently. The original publication record will not be silently altered in a manner that conceals significant corrections or editorial actions.
11. Confidentiality and Fair Treatment
All allegations will be handled with appropriate confidentiality. Information will only be disclosed to individuals or organisations directly involved in the assessment or investigation, where necessary.
Individuals accused of misconduct will be given a reasonable opportunity to respond to allegations before a final determination is made, subject to applicable confidentiality and legal requirements.
The journal will avoid premature public disclosure of unsubstantiated allegations.
12. Protection of Complainants and Whistleblowers
PJIDS encourages individuals to report genuine concerns about research integrity in good faith.
The journal does not tolerate intimidation, harassment, discrimination or retaliation against individuals who raise legitimate concerns or cooperate with investigations.
Knowingly submitting false, malicious or deliberately misleading allegations may itself constitute misconduct and may be referred to an appropriate authority where warranted.
13. Conflicts of Interest in Investigations
Individuals responsible for investigating allegations must disclose any actual, potential or perceived conflicts of interest.
Where a conflict exists, an independent editorial representative or appropriate external expert will be appointed to ensure that the investigation remains impartial.
14. Record Keeping and Documentation
The editorial office will maintain appropriate records of reported allegations, supporting evidence, correspondence, investigation findings and editorial decisions.
Records will be handled securely and retained in accordance with applicable legal, institutional and journal requirements.
15. Appeals and Further Review
Authors or other directly affected parties may request reconsideration of an editorial action where they can provide substantive grounds, relevant new evidence or demonstrate procedural irregularities.
Such requests will be considered in accordance with the journal's Complaints and Appeals Policy.
16. Commitment to Research Integrity
PJIDS is committed to promoting responsible research practices, transparency, accountability and ethical scholarly communication.
The journal will address allegations of research misconduct seriously, objectively and consistently, with the primary aim of protecting the integrity and reliability of the academic record.
17. Contact Information
Reports, concerns or enquiries relating to suspected research misconduct should be directed to the editorial office of the journal through its official contact channel.
Paraskevi Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies (PJIDS)
Paraskevi Academic Dimosiefsi Ltd.
Policy Review: This policy may be reviewed periodically to reflect developments in research integrity, publication ethics and recognised scholarly publishing practices.