Complaints and Appeals Policy
The Paraskevi Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies (PJIDS), published by Paraskevi Academic Dimosiefsi Ltd., is committed to maintaining transparency, fairness, accountability and integrity in all aspects of its scholarly publishing activities. The journal recognises the importance of providing authors, reviewers, readers and other stakeholders with appropriate channels for raising concerns and seeking redress regarding editorial decisions, peer-review procedures and publication practices.
This policy establishes the procedures for receiving, investigating and resolving complaints and appeals in a fair, impartial and timely manner.
1. Scope of the Policy
This policy applies to complaints and appeals relating to the editorial, peer-review and publication activities of PJIDS, including concerns raised by:
- Authors and co-authors.
- Manuscript reviewers.
- Editorial board members.
- Readers and researchers.
- Academic institutions and research organisations.
- Other individuals or organisations with legitimate concerns about published content or journal practices.
2. Types of Complaints
PJIDS accepts complaints relating to the following matters:
- Alleged unfairness or inconsistency in editorial decisions.
- Concerns about the peer-review process.
- Unprofessional conduct by editors, reviewers or journal representatives.
- Delays in manuscript evaluation or publication.
- Conflicts of interest involving authors, reviewers or editors.
- Suspected plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification or other research misconduct.
- Copyright, authorship and publication disputes.
- Breaches of publication ethics or editorial policies.
- Errors in published articles and concerns about corrections or retractions.
- Concerns regarding journal administration and communication.
3. Submission of Complaints
Complaints should be submitted in writing to the editorial office through the journal's official contact channel.
A complaint should contain sufficient information to enable the editorial team to understand and investigate the matter. Where applicable, complainants should provide:
- The name and contact details of the complainant.
- The title of the manuscript or published article concerned.
- The manuscript identification number, where available.
- A clear description of the complaint.
- Relevant dates, correspondence and supporting evidence.
- The action or resolution being requested.
Anonymous complaints may be considered where they contain credible and verifiable information relating to serious ethical or publication concerns.
4. Acknowledgement and Initial Assessment
The editorial office will acknowledge receipt of a complaint and conduct an initial assessment to determine whether the matter falls within the journal's responsibility.
Complaints will be assessed according to their nature, seriousness and available supporting information. Where a complaint concerns an individual editor or editorial board member, that individual shall not be responsible for determining the outcome of the complaint.
5. Investigation and Resolution
Complaints requiring further examination will be investigated impartially and confidentially. The Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately designated independent editorial representative may request additional information from the parties involved.
The investigation may involve:
- Reviewing manuscript records and editorial correspondence.
- Examining reviewer reports and editorial decisions.
- Requesting explanations from the individuals concerned.
- Consulting independent subject specialists or editorial board members.
- Consulting relevant institutional representatives where necessary.
- Considering applicable publication ethics standards.
Following the investigation, the journal will communicate its findings and any appropriate action to the complainant, subject to confidentiality requirements.
6. Appeals Against Editorial Decisions
Authors who disagree with an editorial decision may submit a formal appeal for reconsideration. Appeals may relate to manuscript rejection, editorial handling or concerns about the fairness and appropriateness of the peer-review process.
An appeal must provide clear and substantive reasons for reconsideration. Acceptable grounds may include:
- Evidence of a significant factual misunderstanding in the editorial decision.
- Demonstrable errors or inconsistencies in reviewer assessments.
- Evidence that relevant scientific or scholarly contributions were overlooked.
- Procedural irregularities in the peer-review or editorial process.
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest that may have influenced the decision.
Disagreement with an editorial decision alone, without substantive supporting reasons, may not constitute sufficient grounds for an appeal.
7. Appeal Submission Procedure
Authors submitting an appeal should provide:
- The title of the manuscript and manuscript identification number.
- The original editorial decision being challenged.
- A detailed explanation of the grounds for appeal.
- Point-by-point responses to the relevant reviewer or editorial comments.
- Supporting evidence or additional documentation, where applicable.
Appeals should normally be submitted within 30 days of receiving the editorial decision.
8. Independent Review of Appeals
Appeals will be evaluated by the Editor-in-Chief or an independent editor who was not directly involved in the original decision, where practicable.
Where necessary, the journal may obtain an additional independent expert assessment to support the appeal review.
The outcome of an appeal may include:
- Upholding the original editorial decision.
- Reconsidering the manuscript based on the appeal evidence.
- Requesting additional peer review.
- Reversing the original decision where justified.
- Requesting further revisions or clarification from the authors.
The outcome of the appeal will be communicated to the corresponding author. The appeal decision will normally constitute the journal's final editorial determination.
9. Complaints About Editors and Reviewers
Complaints involving editors, reviewers or other journal representatives will be handled by an appropriate independent authority within the journal's editorial structure.
Where a complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief, the publisher or an independent senior editorial representative will oversee the investigation to prevent conflicts of interest and ensure impartiality.
Appropriate action may include clarification, corrective guidance, removal from a particular editorial assignment or other measures considered necessary.
10. Confidentiality and Protection Against Retaliation
PJIDS will handle complaints and appeals with appropriate confidentiality. Information will only be shared with individuals directly involved in the investigation or resolution of the matter, where necessary.
The journal does not tolerate intimidation, harassment, discrimination or retaliation against individuals who raise legitimate complaints or participate in investigations in good faith.
11. Timeliness of Resolution
The journal aims to acknowledge complaints within five working days of receipt and provide an initial assessment as soon as reasonably practicable.
Where a detailed investigation is required, the complainant will be informed of any significant delays. The time required to reach a final decision will depend on the complexity of the matter and the availability of relevant evidence.
12. Record Keeping
The editorial office will maintain appropriate records of complaints, appeals, investigations, decisions and corrective actions. These records will be handled securely and retained in accordance with the journal's administrative and publication policies.
13. External Escalation
Where a complainant remains dissatisfied with the handling of a matter, they may seek guidance from an appropriate independent scholarly publishing body, professional organisation or relevant institutional authority, where applicable.
Concerns involving research misconduct may also be referred to the relevant author's institution or research organisation where appropriate.
14. Commitment to Fair and Ethical Publishing
PJIDS is committed to resolving complaints and appeals in a manner that promotes fairness, editorial independence, transparency, academic integrity and public confidence in scholarly publishing.
All complaints and appeals will be considered seriously and handled without discrimination or undue influence.
15. Contact Information
All complaints and appeals should be directed to the editorial office of the journal through its official contact channel.
Paraskevi Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies (PJIDS)
Paraskevi Academic Dimosiefsi Ltd.
Policy Review: This policy may be reviewed periodically to ensure continued alignment with recognised scholarly publishing ethics and best practices.