Peer Review Process

PJEHRM operates a double-blind peer-review system.

The identities of authors and reviewers are kept confidential during the review process.

Stage 1: Submission

After submission, the editorial office conducts an initial check for:

  • Scope
  • Originality
  • Completeness
  • Formatting
  • Ethical compliance
  • Similarity/plagiarism
  • Basic scholarly quality

Stage 2: Editorial Screening

The Editor or Managing Editor determines whether the manuscript is suitable for peer review.

A manuscript may be rejected without external review if it is substantially outside the journal's scope or does not meet minimum scholarly or ethical standards.

Stage 3: Reviewer Selection

Appropriately qualified reviewers are selected based on subject expertise and the nature of the manuscript.

Stage 4: Review

Reviewers assess:

  • Originality
  • Relevance
  • Literature review
  • Research design
  • Methodology
  • Analysis
  • Results
  • Discussion
  • Conclusions
  • Contribution to knowledge
  • Ethical considerations
  • Quality of references

Stage 5: Decision

Possible editorial decisions include:

  • Accept
  • Minor Revision
  • Major Revision
  • Revise and Resubmit
  • Reject

Stage 6: Revision

Authors receiving revision requests should respond to reviewer comments and provide a revised manuscript.

Stage 7: Final Decision

The final decision is made by the editorial team after considering reviewer reports and the quality of the revised manuscript.

Reviewer Confidentiality

Reviewers must maintain confidentiality and must not disclose or use unpublished manuscript information for personal or professional advantage